ftance rather difpleafing to a nice ear. The Poem opens thus: Silent Nymph, with curious eye! Draw the landscape bright and strong. Dyer in general wrote with remarkable fimplicity and clearness, but here is an inftance in which his fenfe is almost inexplicable. What fictitious Perfon is addreffed by the appellation of Silent Nymph, it seems scarcely poffible to difcover. Painting, from the expreffions Sifter Mufe, and various hues, might be meant; but why should Painting be defcribed described as lying on the mountain's lonely van? Evening, as a profopopoiea, could not be intended, for Evening cannot with any propriety be faid to paint the form of things. Fancy may be thought to have a better claim to the title, but to her, fome of the above circumftances are not applicable. That Fancy, however, was really defigned, is a fact that can be fully ascertained. Few readers are perhaps apprized that Grongar Hill was originally written, and even printed, as an irregular ode. There is a Miscellany volume of poems, collected and published by the celebrated Richard Savage, in the year 1726, in which it appears in that form, very incorrect, and with the initial lines as follows: FANCY, nymph that loves to lie Darting notice through the eye, Forming thought and feasting sense: G 2 Thou 290868A Thou that muft lend imagination wings, As the paffage ftands at prefent, there must be either a defigned violent elipfis or accidental omiffion of the particle at, in the second line. It might be read thus: Silent nymph with curious eye! The following paragraph rather destroys the unity of defign, by dividing attention between past action, and present, of which laft the principal part of the poem confifts. The image of the poet feated on a bank of flowers, by the fide of a fountain, is nevertheless pretty, and has perhaps merit enough to justify its retention: Grongar, in whose moffy cells Sat Sat upon a flowery bed, With my hand beneath my head; While stray'd my eyes o'er Towy's flood, Over mead and over wood, From house to houfe, from hill to hill, The author now agreeably describes the circumstance of ascending a hill, with the confequent gradual enlargement of the surrounding horizon. The trite fimile of circles on water, is here happily applied. The comparison of material with metaphorical eminence, unhappy fate, &c. interrupts the defcription, and is not ftrictly just; mountains finking in appearance from a fpectator's change of fituation, can have no real analogy with the degradation of a statesman, hero, or other elevated character. The ideas in thefe couplets, Still the prospect, wider, &c.' are so extensive, that they approach to the true fublime : About his chequer'd fides I wind, And leave his brooks and meads behind, And viftas fhooting beams of day: Wide and wider spreads the vale; Withdraw their fummits from the skies, And leffen as the others rife : Still the profpect wider spreads, Adds a thousand woods and meads, And finks the newly-risen hill. Some readers may think the following alterations no improvement, but the arrangement is certainly preferable in in point of correctness Wider and wider spreads the vale, As circles on a smooth canal; The mountains round that reach the skies Still the profpect, &c. Had all the next paragraph except the first two lines, been fuppreffed, the poem would have fuffered no material lofs, After the landscape was faid to lye below, it was furely needless to say that it spread beneath the fight; nor does the face of Nature, |