884 935 Page (Pa.) 415 (Pa.) 297 648 650 State Philadelphia & R. R. Co., Johnson v. Pittsburg, S. & N. R. Co. v. Keating & S. Rockwell v. American Law Book Co. (N J.) 1134 Roe, Doe ex dem. Littleton v. (Del. Super.) .... 47 Roe, Huston v. (N. J.). 848 Roe, Littleton v. (Del. Super.). 47 Rogers v. Bailey (N. J.). ..1134 Platt Bros. & Co., Belevicze v. (Conn.).. 339 Rogers v. Clough (N. H.) ..1075 420 Rogers, Covey v. (Vt.). .1130 724 V. Roschen v. Packard (Md.). Roscoe, Bixby v. (Vt.). (Pa.) 148 Poe, Preston v. (Md.) 178 Potomac Valley Coal Co. of Garrett Coun ty, State v. (Md.). 686 Rosen, New Jersey Soc. for Prevention of 955 Pottle v. Liverpool & London & Globe Ins. Co. (Me.).. 481 Powell, Miller v. (Vt.). 921 Powell v. Old Town (Me.). .1068 Rushe v. Hyattsville (Md.). 278 Power v. Grogan (Pa.).. Prescott v. Angell (R. I.).. Preston v. Poe (Md.). 416 Ruskin v. Armn (N. J. Sup.).. 342 194 Russell, Allen & Reed v. (R. I.) 438 108 Preston v. Safe Deposit & Trust Co. (Md.) 523 664 983 .1093 Russell v. Henry C. Patterson Co. (Pa.).. 136 548 State v. 252 Primrose v. Casualty Co. of America (Pa.) 212 129 Prout v. Prout (N. J.).. 757 Public Service Corp. of New Jersey, Nevin v. (N. J. Sup.).. 838 St. Johnsbury & L. C. R. Co., Bell's Estate v. (Vt.)... 630 Public Service Corp. of New Jersey, Reis Sallies v. Johnson (Conn.) 974 man v. (N. J.). 840 Public Service Corp. of New Jersey, Taylor v. (N. J.).. .1134 Samkiwicz v. Atlantic City R. Co. (N. J.) 833 S. Anderson & Son v. Shattuck (N. H.)... Sanford Co., Manns v. (N. J. Sup.) 781 491 Public Service R. Co. v. Board of Public Putt v. Africa (Pa.).. P. Welty & Co., Betz v. (Md.). Quade v. Columbia & P. D. R. Co. (Pa.).. 813 Radcliffe, Krah v. (N. J.). Sedgwick, State v. (Del. Gen. Sess.).. 472 1133 See v. Public Service R. Co. (N. J. Sup.).. 745 .1103 Selectmen of Town of Montville v. Alpha Saperstein, Goodman v. (Md.) Sawyer, McCormick v. (Me.). Sawyer, Smith v. (Me.). 695 482 868 Schaffer v. Levenson Wrecking Co. (N. J. Sup.) 434 ... Schaub v. O'Ferrall (Md.). 789 Schmitt, Johnson v. (N. J.). .1133 Schneider v. Mueller (N. J.) Schoenfeld v. Winter (N. J.). Scull v. Idler (N. J. Ch.). 863 .1134 746 Rand v. Bordo (Vt.).. 251 Randal, Gould v. (Pa.). 809 Randall, Davis v. (Vt.). 250 Selinas, Donovan v. (Vt.). 235 Randell, Sprowl v. (Me.). 80 Semkin v. Hollander (N. J.). 980 Raymond v. Parker (Conn.).. .1030 Readsboro Chair Mfg. Co., Bishop v. (Vt.) 454 Reeside, Oberheim v. (Md.). 590 Reisman v. Public Service Corp. of New Jersey (N. J.)... 838 Reisman v. Public Service Corp. of New 586 Shepherd & Sons v. First Nat. Bank (Pa.) 715 Shick, Appeal of (Pa.)... 212 Renehan, McAvoy v. (Md.) 673 Shine v. District Court of City of Orange Rentschler, Moyer v. (Pa.). 52 (N. J. Sup.)... 499 Repp, Marter v. (N. J.)... .1134 Reynolds, Horner v. (N. H.) .1078 Shoemaker & Co. v. Board of Health of Gloucester City (N. J. Sup.). 349 Reynolds, Trexler v. (Pa.). Rhodes' Estates, In re (Pa.).. 643 Simpson Plumbing & Heating Co. V. Rhone v. Sperry & Barnes Co. (Conn.).... Richards v. Naudain (Del. Super.) 100 Geschke (N. J.).. .1133 872 Sims v. O'Flaherty (Conn.) .1026 Rick v. New York, C. & St. L. R. Co. (Pa.) 650 Riefler & Sons v. Wayne Storage Water Power Co. (Pa.). Singer's Estate, In re (Pa.) 898 300 Sisters of Charity of St. Elizabeth v. Morris R. Co. (N. J. Sup.)... 817 Riffert v. Lehigh Valley Coal Co. (Pa.)... 810 Rimmer v. Aachen & Munich Fire Ins. Co. (R. I.).... Skeels v. Blanchard (Vt.) 913 Slack & Bro., Frazier v. (Vt.). 161 977 Slayton v. Davis (Vt.). 232 Rittenhouse v. Newhard (Pa.). 445 Smith, Appeal of (Pa.).. 64 Riva v. Jersey City, H. & P. St. R. Co. (N. J.).. Smith, Appeal of (Pa.). 643 847 Smit v. Abbott (N. J. Ch.).. 115 Smith v. Lehigh Val. R. Co. (Pa.). 743 Stover v. Steffey (Md.). 554 Strausbaugh, Caslow v. (Pa.). Smith v. Philadelphia & R. R. Co. (Pa.).. 297 Streeter, State v. (Vt.).. Smith v. Sawyer (Me.). Smith v. Warrenfeltz (Md.). Smith v. Wilson (N. J. Ch.). Smith Co., Sterner v. (Pa.).... S. Morgan Smith Co., Sterner v. (Pa.) 868 Strickland v. National Salt Co. (N. J.) 275 Strickland v. National Salt Co. (N. J.). 851 Strock v. East Orange (N. J.) 33 927 923 828 832 ...826 889 Strong, Appeal of (Conn.).. .1020 889 Strout Co., Light v. (Me.). 867 Snelling & Potter v. Merritt (Conn.).....1039 Sondergaard, Nagle v. (N. J. Ch.).... 841 Sopp, Bergdoll v. (Pa.). 62 Sullivan, Zabriskie v. (N. J.). Sullivan County R. R., In re (N. H.). Sutherland v. Brown (Conn.). ...1135 473 ..1033 Southard, Moran v. (Me.)... .1132 Southern Can Co., Clark v. (Md.) Sower, Appeal of (Pa.).. 207 Tarlucki v. West Jersey & S. R. Co. (N. J. Sowles v. Hartford Life Ins. Co. (Vt.).. Sperry & Barnes Co., Rhone v. (Conn.).. Sprowl v. Randell (Me.).. 98 Sup.) 495 Squire, Hauser v. (N. J. Sup.). 263 Taylor, Firor v. (Md.). 389 Standard Arms Co., Du Pont v. (Del. Ch.)1089 Standard Distilling & Distributing Co., Bijur v. (N. J.).. .1132 Taylor v. Public Service Corp. of New Jersey (N. J.)..... ...1134 Standard Soap & Oil Co. v. Printz Degreas ing Co. (Pa.)... 129 Taylor Provision Co. v. Edwards (N. J.)..1120 Thielbahr, Shaw v. (N. J. Sup.) 497 Stanton, Lapp v. (Md.). 675 Thomas, In re (Conn.) 972 State v. Averill (Vt.). State v. Bowman (N. J. Sup.). 561 Thompson, Henry v. (N. J.) 840 State v. Carruth (Vt.) 922 Thorpe v. Fales (R. I.). 721 State, Conococheague Club of Washington County v. (Md.).. 602 Thorson v. Groton & S. St. R. Co. (Conn.) .. ...1024 State v. Cray (Vt.)... 450 Tidewater Coal Co., Edward Knapp & Co. State, Crichton v. (Md.) 36 V. (Conn.). .1063 State v. Drown (Vt.) 641 Tingier v. Woodruff (Conn.). 967 401 Tischman v. Erie R. Co. (N. J. Sup.).... 10 Title Guaranty & Surety Co., Brown v. (Pa.) .... 114 410 ... State v. Hamill Coal & Coke Co. (Md.) State v. Hastings (Del. Gen. Sess.). State, Hendrick v. (Md.).. .... 403 695 Tobyhanna Co., Delaware, L. & W. R. Co. v. (Pa.).. 132 State, Hendrick v. (Md.). State v. Johnson (N. J. Sup.). 18 Tomlinson, In re (Del. Orph.). 22 Tomlinson, In re (Del. Orph.). 657 Tonns v. Collins (Md.). 468 585 219 State, Luery v. (Md.).. 681 Towmbly v. Morris R. Co. (N. J. Sup.). 817 State, Luery v. (Md.) 685 State v. Parshley (Me.).. 484 Town of Bloomfield, American Malleable Co. v. (N. J. Sup.)... 500 State v. Potomac Valley Coal Co. of Garrett County (Md.). 686 Town of Guilford, Town of Madison v. (Conn.) State v. Rutland Ry., Light & Power Co. (Vt.) Town of Hyattsville, Carr v. (Md.) .1046 S 252 State v. Sedgwick (Del. Gen. Sess.). 472 State v. Streeter (Vt.) 923 873 Town of Morristown v. Murphy (N. J. Sup.) 498 606 State Board of Assessors, Central R. R. of New Jersey v. (N. J. Sup.). 568 State Board of Assessors, Long Dock Co. v. (N. J. Sup.). 568 State Board of Assessors, Morris & E. R. State Board of Assessors, Phillipsburg, 568 Town of Waterford, Comstock v. (Conn.)1059 244 Town of West New York, Hornung v. (N. J. Sup.)... ...1116 351 State Board of Education, Board of Education of Borough of Flemington v. (N. Town of Winchester v. Moriarty (Conn.) 965 526 405 J. Sup.)..... 163 Steel v. Linn (Pa.).. 92 Steffey, Stover v. (Md.). 33 Township of Bradford, Cobb v. (Pa.).... 199 Township of Butler, Hoch v. (Pa.)... Township of Hanover, McManamon v. 546 Stegmaier v. Keystone Coal Co. (Pa.).... 187 (Pa.) 440 Steinfeld Bros., Imperial Rolling Screen Co. v. (Pa.). Trexler, Africa v. (Pa.). 707 413 Trexler v. Reynolds (Pa.).. 194 Sterner v. S. Morgan Smith Co. (Pa.). Stillwagon, Howard v. (Pa.). ... 807 Stinson's Estate, In re (Pa.).. 207 Troxell, North Mountain Water Supply Co. v. (Pa.)..... 157 Stinson's Estate, In re (l'a.). 212 Trustees of Dummer Academy v. Banks Stirk's Estate, In re (Pa.). Stock & Sons, Catanzaro Di Giorgio Co. v. (Md.) 385 Trustees of Mut. Loan Ass'n v. Tyre (Del. Super.) 48 Stockwell, Town of Winchester v., two cases (N. H.).. 526 ... Stout v. Cook (N. J.). Stokes, Atlantic Refining Co. v. (N. J.)..1132 Stokes v. Mason (Vt.).. Trustees of Seventh Baptist Church of Baltimore v. Andrew & Thomas (Md.).. Tudor, Kennett v. (Vt.)... 1 633 162 Tunis, City of Newark v. (N. J.) 722 221 THE ATLANTIC REPORTER VOLUME 81 (115 Md. 535) TRUSTEES OF SEVENTH BAPTIST (Court of Appeals of Maryland. June 22, 1. APPEAL AND ERROR (§ 1047*)-HARMLESS [Ed. Note.-For other cases, see Appeal and Error, Cent. Dig. §§ 4146-4152; Dec. Dig. 8 1047.*] 2. PRINCIPAL AND SURETY (§ 100*)-CHANGE OF CONTRACT. Where a building contract specified lime mortar plaster as that which should be used, the contractor's sureties would not be liable for damages resulting from using a patent plaster of a different kind with the approval of the architect without their consent. BRISCOE, J. On the 2d day of August, 1907, the appellant brought suit in the superior court of Baltimore city against Andrew & Thomas, contractors, as principals, and the appellee, as surety, on a bond, conditioned for the faithful performance of a building contract, for the erection and construction of a church, at the northwest corner of North avenue and St. Paul street, in the city of Baltimore. On the 25th of September, 1909, a judgment was entered in favor of the defendants Andrew & Thomas, on a plea of discharge in bankruptcy, and the case was subsequently tried against the surety, the American Bonding Company of Baltimore city, the appellee here. The particular breach of the bond assigned by the amended declaration is that Andrew & Thomas, the principals named in the bond, did not do and finish the work on the church according to the plans and specifications in the contract, in that they did defective work and used improper materials in plastering the church, that the plastering became loose, a part of it fell, and other parts thereof became and were liable to fall at any time, and that the plaintiff was compelled to remove the defective plaster and replace it with good and proper plaster at a large cost and expense. The bond, contract, specifications, and a bill of particulars were filed with the amended declaration and appear in the record. Το this declaration the defendant pleaded 19 special pleas, and to these were interposed in turn by the plaintiff and defendant numerous demurrers, replications, and rejoinders, and finally resulted in 26 issues in form, being joined, but which as stated by the appelAppeal from Superior Court of Baltimore lant in its brief, actually and in fact, can be City; Alfred S. Niles, Judge. [Ed. Note. For other cases, see Principal and Surety, Cent. Dig. §§ 162-165; Dec. Dig. 8 100.*] 3. PRINCIPAL AND SURETY (§ 59*)-CONSTRUCTION OF CONTRACT. A surety's liability cannot be extended by construction beyond the limits fixed by the con tract. [Ed. Note. For other cases, see Principal and Surety, Cent. Dig. §§ 103, 1032; Dec. Dig. §tive 59.*] 4. CONTRACTS (§ 284*)-BUILDING CONTRACTS -ARCHITECT'S APPROVAL-EFFECT. Where a building contract made the architect's decision conclusive on all matters referred to him, the owner could not recover damages for defective plastering if the plaster work was approved by the architect after completion. [Ed. Note.-For other cases, see Contracts, Cent. Dig. $$ 1292-1302, 1308-1317, 1326 1338; Dec. Dig. § 284.*] Action by the Trustees of the Seventh Baptist Church of Baltimore against Andrew & Thomas and another. From a judgment for defendants, plaintiffs appeal. Affirmed. Argued before BOYD, C. J., and BRISCOE, PEARCE, PATTISON, and URNER, JJ. S. S. Field and Alfred Bagby, Jr., for appellants. Edward Duffy, for appellees. treated as 6 issues. We have examined the voluminous pleadings, as set out in the record in this case, with considerable care, and we find no reversible error in the rulings of the court thereon. None were seriously urged at the hearing of the case in argument, and none are pointed out or insisted upon in the appellants' brief. For other cases see same topic and section NUMBER in Dec. Dig. & Am. Dig. Key No. Series & Rep'r Indexes 81 A.-1 |