Page images
PDF
EPUB

MacIntyre, Ian.

Sandon, Lord. McLean, Maj. A.

Sassoon, Sir Philip Albert Gustave D. Macmillan, Capt. H.

Savery, S. S. Macnaghten, Hon. Sir Malcolm. Shaw, R. G. Macquisten, F. A.

Shaw, Lieut. Col. A. D. McI. Maitland, Sir Arthur D. Steel-.

Sheffield, Sir Berkeley. Makins, Brig. Gen. E.

Skelton, A. N. Margesson, Capt. D.

Smith, R. W. Marriott, Sir J. A. R.

Smithers, Waldron. Mason, Col. Glyn K.

Spender-Clay, Col. H. Milne, J. S. Wardlaw

Stanley, Lord. Mitchell, s.

Stanley, Hon. 0. F. G. Mitchell, W. Foot.

Steel, Maj. Samuel Strang. Mitchell, Sir W. Lane.

Stott, Lieut. Col. W. H. Monsell, Eyres, Com. Right Hon. B. M. Stuart, Crichton-, Lord C. Moore, Sir Newton J.

Stuart, Hon. J. Moreing, Capt. A. H.

Sueter, Rear Admiral Murray Fraser. Nall, Col. Sir Joseph.

Sugden, Sir Wilfrid. Nelson, Sir Frank.

Tasker, R. Inigo. Newton, Sir D. G. C.

Templeton, W. P. Nicholson, O.

Thom, Lieut. Col. J. G. Nicholson, Col. Right Hon. W. G. Thompson,

Luke. Owen, Maj. G.

Thomson, F. C. Pennefather, Sir John.

Thomson, Right Hon. Sir W. Mitchell-, Penny, Frederick George.

Titchfield, Maj. the Marquess of. Perkins, Col. E. K.

Tryon, Right Hon. George Clement. Perring, Sir Willaim George.

Vaughan-Morgan, Col. K. P. Peto, G.

Warner, Brig. Gen. W. W. Preston, Sir Walter.

Warrender, Sir Victor. Price, Maj. C. W. M.

Waterhouse, Capt. Charles. Raine, Sir Walter.

Watson, Right Hon. W. Rees, Sir Beddoe.

Watts, Sir Thomas. Reid, D. D.

Wells, S. R. Rentoul, G. S.

White, Lieut. Col. Sir G. Dalymple-. Richardson, Sir P. W.

Williams, A. M. Rodd, Right Hon. Sir James Rennell. Williams, Com. C. Ruggles-Brise, Lieut. Col. E. A.

Wilson, R. R. Russell, Alexander West.

Wolmer, Viscount. Salmon, Maj. I.

Womersley, W. J. Samuel, A. M.

Wood, Right Hon. Sir Kingsley. Samuel, Samuel.

Worthington-Evans, Right Hon. Sir L. Sandeman, N. Stewart.

Wright, Brig. Gen. W. V. Sanders, Sir Robert A.

Tellers for the ayes: Captain Wallace and Captain Bowyer.

NOES

Adamson, Right Hon. W.
Adamson, W. M.
Alexander, A. V.
Ammon, Charles George.
Baker, Walter.
Barker, G.
Barr, J.
Batey, Joseph.
Beckett, John.
Bellamy, A.
Benn, Wedgwood.
Bondfield, Margaret.
Bowerman, Right Hon. Charles W.
Briant, Frank.
Broad, F. A.
Brown, James.
Buchanan, G.
Cape, Thomas.
Charleton, H. C.
Cluse, W.'s.

Clynes, Right Hon. John R.
Compton, Joseph.
Connolly, M.
Cove, W. G.
Dalton, Hugh.
Davies, Evan.
Davies, Rhys John.
Day, Harry.
Dunnico, 8.
Edwards, c.
Gardner, J. P.
Garro-Jones, Capt. G. M.
Gibbins, Joseph
Gillett, George M.
Gosling, Harry.
Graham, D. M.
Graham, Right Hon. Wm.
Greenall, T.
Greenwood, A.
Grenfell, D. R.

Griffith, F. Kingsley.

Riley, Ben. Griffiths, T.

Ritson, J. Grundy, T. W.

Roberts, Right Hon. F. 0. Hall, T.

Saklatvala, Shapurji. Hardie, George D.

Salter, Dr. Alfred. Hayday, Arthur

Scrymgeour, E. Henderson, Right Hon. A.

Scurr, John. Henderson, T.

Shaw, Right Hon. Thomas. Hirst, G. H.

Shepherd, Arthur Lewis. Hirst, w.

Shiels, Dr. Drummond. Hudson, J. H.

Shinwell, E. Jenkins, w.

Smillie, Robert. John, William.

Smith, Ben. Jones, J. J.

Snell, Harry. Jones, Morgan

Snowden, Řight Hon. Philip. Jones, I Mardy.

Stamford,

T. W. Kelly, W. T.

Stephen, Campbell. Kennedy, T.

Stewart, J. Kenworthy, Lieut. Commander Hon. Sullivan, J. Joseph M.

Sutton, J. E. Kirkwood, D.

Taylor, R. A. Lawrence, Susan.

Thurtle, Ernest. Lawson, John James.

Tinker, John Joseph. Lee, F.

Tomlinson, R. P. Longbottom, A. W.

Townend, A. E. Lunn, William.

Trevelyan, Right Hon. Sir Charles. MacDonald, Right Hon. J. R.

Vlant, S. P. Mackinder, W.

Wallhead, Richard C. Malone, C. L'Estrange.

Walsh, Right Hon. Stephen. March, s.

Watson, W. M. Maxton, James.

Wedgwood, Right Hon. Josiah. Montague, Frederick.

Wellock, Wilfred. Morrison, R. C.

Welsh, J. C. Mosley, Sir Oswald.

Westwood, J. Murnin, H.

Wheatley, Right Hon. J. Naylor, T. E.

Wilkinson, Ellen C. Oliver, George Harold.

Williams, David Palin, John Henry.

Williams, Dr. J. H. Paling, W.

Williams, T. Parkinson, John Allen.

Wilson, C. H. Pethick, Lawrence, F. W.

Wilson, R. J. Ponsonby, Arthur.

Windsor, Walter. Potts, John S.

Wright, w. Purcell, A. A.

Young, Robert Richardson, R.

Tellers for the noes: Mr. A. Barnes and Mr. Whiteley.

Mr. W. BAKER. I beg to move, in page 3, line 24, after the word "may, insert the words: “at a price to be approved by a resolution of the Hou Commons."

(Question put, “That those words be there inserted.") The committee divided: Ayes, 128; noes, 213.

AYES

Adamson, Right Hon. W.
Adamson, W. M.
Alexander, A. V.
Ammon, Charles George.
Baker, J.
Baker, Walter.
Barker, G.
Barr, J.
Beckett, John.
Bellamy, A.
Benn, Wedgwood.
Bondfield, Margaret.

.

Bowerman, Right Hon. Charles W
Briant, Frank
Broad, F. A.
Brown, James.
Buchanan, G.
Cape, Thomas.
Charleton, H. C.
Cluse, W.'s.
Clynes, Right Hon. John R.
Compton, Joseph.
Connolly, M.
Cove, W. G.

Dalton, Hugh.

Paling, W. Davies, Rhys John.

Parkinson, John Allen. Day, Harry.

Pethick-Lawrence, F. W. Dunnico, Å.

Ponsonby, Arthur. Edwards, c.

Potts, John S. Gardner, J. P.

Purcell, A. A. Garro-Jones, Capt. G. M.

Richardson, R. Gibbins, Joseph.

Riley, Ben. Gillett, George M.

Ritson, J. Gosling, Harry.

Roberts, Right Hon. F. O. Graham, D. M.

Saklatvala, Shapurji. Graham, Right Hon. Wm.

Salter, Dr. Alfred. Greenall, T.

Scrymgeour, E. Greenwood, A.

Scurr, John. Grenfell, D. R.

Shaw, Right Hon. Thomas.
Griffith, F. Kingsley.

Shiels, Dr. Drummond.
Griffiths, T. (Monmouth, Pontypool). Shinwell, E.
Grundy, T. W.

Smillie, Robert.
Hall, F.

Smith, Ben. Hardle, George D.

Snell, Harry. Hayday, Arthur.

Snowden, Right Hon. Philip. Henderson, Right Hon. A.

Stamford, T. W. Henderson, T.

Stephen, Campbell. Hirst, G. H.

Stewart, J. Hirst, w.

Sullivan, Joseph. Hudson, J. H.

Sutton, J. E. Jenkins, w

Taylor, R. A. John, William.

Thomas, Right Hon. James H. Jones, J. J.

Thorne, W. Jones, Morgan.

Thurtle, Ernest. Kelly, W. T.

Tinker, John Joseph. Kennedy, T.

Tomlinson, R. P. Kenworthy, Lieut. Commander Hon. Townend, A. E. Joseph M.

Trevelyan, Right Hon. Sir Charles. Kirkwood, D.

Viant, S. P. Lawrence, Susan.

Wallhead, Richard C. Lawson, John James.

Walsh, Right Hon. Stephen. Lee, F.

Watson, W. M. Longbottom, A. W.

Wedgwood, Right Hon. Josiah. Lunn, William.

Wellock, Wilfred. MacDonald, Right Hon. J. R.

Welsh, J. C. Mackinder, W.

Westwood, J. Malone, C. L'Estrange.

Wheatley, Right Hon. J. March, 's.

Wilkinson, Ellen C. Maxton, James.

Williams, David. Montague, Frederick.

Williams, Dr. J. H. Morrison, R. C.

Williams, T. Mosley, Sir Oswald.

Wilson, C. H. Murnin, H.

Wilson, R. J. Naylor,'T. E.

Windsor, Walter. Newman, Sir R. H. S. D. L.

Wright, w. Oliver, George Harold.

Young, Robert. Palin, John Henry.

Tellers for the ayes: Mr. A. Barnes and Mr. Whiteley.

NOES
Albery, Irving James.

Banks, Sir Reginald Mitchell,
Amery, Right Hon. Leopold C. M. S. Barclay-Harvey, C. M.
Applin, Col. R. V. K.

Beckett, Sir Gervase.
Apsley, Lord.

Bellairs, Commander Carlyon.
Ashley, Lieut. Col. Right Hon. Wilfrid Benn, Sir A. S.
W.

Bennett, A. J.
Atholl, Duchess of.

Berry, Sir George. Baldwin, Right Hon. Stanley.

Birchall, Maj. J. Dearman. Balfour, George.

Bird, E. R. Balniel, Lord.

Bourne, Capt. Robert Croft. 5101429-PT 8-27

Bowater, Col. Sir T. Vansittart.
Braithwaite, Maj. A. N.
Briscoe, Richard George.
Brocklebank, C. E. R.
Brooke, Brig. Gen. C. R. I.
Brown, Brig. Gen. H. C.
Brown, Ernest.
Bullock, Capt. M.
Burman, J. B.
Burton, Col. H. W.
Caine, Gordon Hall.
Cassels, J. D.
Cautley, Sir Henry S.
Cayzer, Sir C.
Cayzer, Maj. Sir Herbert R.
Cecil, Right Hon. Sir Evelyn.
Chamberlain, Right Hon. N.
Charteris, Brig. Gen. J.
Christie, J. A.
Clayton, G. C.
Cochrane, Commander Hon. A. D.
Colfox, Maj. William Phillips.
Cooper, A. Duff.
Cope, Maj. Sir William.
Couper, J. B.
Cowan, Sir William Henry.
Craig, Sir Ernest.
Crooke, J. Smedley.
Culverwell, C. T.
Davies, Sir Thomas.
Davies, Dr. Vernon.
Davison, Sir W. H.
Dawson, Sir Philip.
Dean, Arthur Wellesley.
Drewe, C.
Edge, Sir William.
Edmondson, Maj. A. J.
Elliot, Maj. Walter E.
Ellis, R. G.
Erskine, Lord.
Erskine, James Malcolm Monteith.
Evans, Capt. A.
Evans, Capt. Ernest.
Everard, W. Lindsay.
Falle, Sir Bertram Ĝ.
Fanshawe, Capt. G. D.
Fenby, T. D.
Fermoy, Lord.
Ford, Sir P. J.
Forrest, W.
Foster, Sir Harry S.
Foxcroft, Capt. C. T.
Fraser, Capt. Ian.
Fremantle, Lieut. Col. Francis E.
Gadle, Lieut. Col. Anthony.
Galbraith, J. F. W.
Ganzoni, Sir John.
Gates, Percy.
Gault, Lieut. Col. Andrew Hamilton.
Gilmour, Lieut. Col. Right Hon. Sir

John.
Glyn, Maj. R. G. C.
Goff, Sir Park.
Grace, John.
Grant, Sir J. A.
Greaves-Lord, Sir Walter.
Grenfell, Edward C.

Grotrian, H. Brent.
Guinness, Right Hon. Walter E.
Gunston, Capt. D. W.
Hacking, Douglas H.
Hall, Lieut. Col. Sir F.
Hall, Capt. W. D'A.
Hammersley, S. S.
Hannon, Patrick Joseph Henry.
Harland, A.
Hartington, Marquess of.
Harvey, Maj. S. É.
Haslam, Henry C.
Henderson, Capt. R. R.
Heneage, Lieut. Col. Arthur P.
Henn, Sir Sydney H.
Hennessy, Maj. Sir G. R. J.
Herbert, s.
Hills, Maj. John Waller.
Hilton, Cecil.
Hoare, Lieut. Col. Right Hon. Sir

J. G.
Hope, Sir Harry.
Howard-Bury, Col. C. K.
Hudson, Capt. A. U. M.
Hudson, R. S.
Hume, Sir G. H.
Hunter-Weston, Lieut. Gen. Sir A

mer.
Hurd, Percy A.
Hutchison, Sir Robert.
Iliffe, Sir Edward M.
James, Lieut. Col. Hon. Cuthbert.
King, Commodore Henry Douglas.
Kinloch-Cooke, Sir Clement.
Knox, Sir Alfred.
Lamb, J. Q.
Lister, Cunliffe, Right Hon. Sir Phi
Livingstone, A. M.
Loder, J. de V.
Long, Maj. Eric.
Looker, Herbert William.
Luce, Maj. Gen. Sir Richard Harm
Lynn, Sir R. J.
MacAndrew, Maj. Charles Glen.
Macdonald, Capt. P. D.
MacIntyre, Ian.
McLean, Maj. A.
Macmillan, Capt. H.
Macnaghten, Hon. Sir Malcolm.
Macquisten, F. A.
Maitland, Sir Arthur D. Steel-,
Makins, Brig. Gen. E.
Margesson, Capt. D.
Marriott, Sir J. A. R.
Mason, Col. Glyn K.
Milne, J. S. Wardlaw-.
Micthell, s.
Mitchell, W. Foot.
Mitchell, Sir W. Lane.
Monsell, Eyres, Com. Right H

B. M.
Moore, Sir Newton J.
Moreing, Capt. A. H.
Nall, Col. Sir Joseph.
Nelson, Sir Frank.
Newton, Sir D. G. C.
Nicholson, O.

Nicholson, Col. Right Hon. W. G. Stanley, Hon. 0. F. G.
Owen, Maj. G.

Steel, Maj. Samuel Strang.
Penny, Ferderick George.

Stott, Lieut. Col. W. H. Perkins, Col. E. K.

Stuart, Crichton-, Lord C. Perring, Sir William George.

Stuart, Hon. J. Peto, G.

Sueter, Rear Admiral Murray Fraser. Preston, Sir Walter.

Sugden, Sir Wilfrid. Price, Maj. C. W. M.

Tasker, R. Inigo. Raine, Sir Walter.

Templeton, W. P. Rees, Sir Beddoe.

Thom, Lieut, Col. J. G. Reid, D. D.

Thompson, Luke. Rentoul, G. S.

Thomson, F. C. Richardson, Sir P. W.

Thomson, Right Hon. Sir W Mitchell. Rodd, Right Hon. Sir James Rennell. Titchfield, Maj., the Marquess of. Ruggles-Brise, Lieut. Col. E. A. Tryon, Right Hon. George Clement. Russell, Alexander West.

Vaughan-Morgan, Col. K. P. Salmon, Maj. I.

Warner, Brig. Gen. W. W. Samuel, A. M.

Warrender, Sir Victor. Samuel, Samuel.

Waterhouse, Capt. Charles. Sandeman, N. Stewart.

Watson, Right Hon. W. Sanders, Sir Robert A.

Watts, Sir Thomas. Sandon, Lord.

Wells, S. R. Sassoon, Sir Philip Albert Gustave D. White, Lieut. Col. Sir G. Dalrymple-. Savery, S. S.

Williams, A. M. Shaw, R. G.

Williams, Com. C. Shaw, Lieut. Col. A. D. McI.

Wilson, Á. R. Sheffield, Sir Berkeley.

Windsor-Clive, Lieut. Col. George. Skelton, A. N.

Wolmer, Viscount. Smith, R. W.

Womersley, W. J. Smithers, Waldron.

Wood, Right Hon. Sir Kingsley. Spender-Clay, Col. H.

Worthington-Evans, Right Hon. Sir L. Stanley, Lord.

Wright, Brig. Gen. W. D. Tellers for the noes: Captain Wallace and Captain Bowyer. The DEPUTY CHAIRMAN (Mr. Dennis Herbert). Mr. Ammon. Mr. Benn. On a point of order. I handed in a manuscript amendment, in line 25, to leave out the words "communications company."

The DEPUTY CHAIRMAN. I will ask the honorable member to explain how he would make any sense at all.

Mr. BENN. It is the custom of the house to move to leave out words or subsections in order to get an explanation. It is true that the amendment does not read, but it is put with the customary practice of getting an explanation.

The DEPUTY CHAIRMAN. An amendment which is moved for that purpose must be of such a form as to be effective and one which would not have the effect of making the bill absurd. The honorable member's amendment is to leave out the words "communications company," but they really must be included because the whole of the rest of the bill is based upon what will be arranged with the communications company.

Mr. Benn. Would it be in order to leave out the words “to the communications company''? That would make sense.

The DEPUTY CHAIRMAN. No, I am afraid it would not. The honorable member has to make some totally different alteration. This communications company is referred to all through the bill.

Mr. BENN. I will refer to it on the question, “That the clause stand part of the bill."

Mr. Ammon. I beg to move, in page 3, line 27, to leave out the words “twentyeight” and to insert instead thereof the word “thirty.'

This may seem quite a trivial matter, but, having regard to the discussions which have taken place this afternoon and on previous occasions, it is more important than appears at first blush. We have had great difficulty in getting the necessary information in order to understand all the implications of this bill and all that has transpired previous to its appearance. Within the last few minutes, we have had from the secretary of state for the Dominions the reply to a question to which we have been striving to get an answer for six months. That is an indication of our difficulties. I am moving to alter the date in order that we may be supplied with fuller information particularly with regard to the

« ՆախորդըՇարունակել »